RILEY DAVIDSON v. SHELBYVILLE HOSPITAL COMPANY, LLC - Articles

All Content

RILEY DAVIDSON v. SHELBYVILLE HOSPITAL COMPANY, LLC

Posted by: Azya Thornton on Jun 3, 2026

Court: TN Court of Appeals

Attorneys 1: W. Bryan Smith and Chad D. Graddy, Memphis, Tennessee, for the appellant, Riley Davidson.

Attorneys 2: Heather M. Gwinn, James R. Embrey, Jr., and Lauren S. Spicer, Franklin, Tennessee, for the appellee, Shelbyville Hospital Company, LLC.

Judge(s): DAVIS

This appeal arises out of a health care liability claim. The case proceeded to trial, and the jury entered a verdict in favor of the appellee-defendant. The appellant-plaintiff appeals the trial court’s acceptance of two of defendant’s expert witnesses. Upon diligent review of the record, we conclude that the trial court erred in allowing defendant’s causation expert witness to testify about his interpretation of a diagnostic image when his opinion about that image had not been properly disclosed as required by the Tennessee Rules of Civil Procedure. We also conclude that this error more probably than not affected the judgment. We further conclude that the trial court erred in allowing defendant’s standard-of-care expert witness to testify despite not satisfying the locality rule contained in the Health Care Liability Act. However, we conclude that this error did not more probably than not affect the judgment. We vacate the jury’s verdict and the trial court’s judgment and remand this matter for a new trial.

Attachments: