Franklin-based Acadia Healthcare, one of the nation’s largest operators of psychiatric hospitals and treatment facilities, is the subject of a New York Times investigation. The newspaper looks into allegations that the hospital chain "lured patients into its facilities and held them against their will, even when detaining them was not medically necessary" in order to bill the patients' insurance, rather than out of a need for medical treatment. Tim Blair, an Acadia spokesman, said the patient examples cited by news outlet were not representative of many patients with positive experiences. Behavioral Health Business reports on the Times coverage, which focused primarily on four hospitals in Florida, Georgia and Missouri over a five-year period.

The Daily Memphian has an in depth look at the increasing number of women judges across the state, which is leading to an increase in mentors for new female judges — a development Supreme Court Chief Justice Holly Kirby says is a sign of progress for the legal profession. Today, one third of Tennessee's 230 judges are women, including Kirby, who was the first woman to serve on the Tennessee Court of Appeals and is the fourth female chief justice. Other "firsts" in the state include Bernice Donald, who was the first Black female judge in Tennessee when she was elected to Shelby County General Sessions Criminal Court in 1982 and was the first Black female judge in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court and U.S. 6th Circuit Court of Appeals. Julia Smith Gibbons became the first female trial court judge of record when she was appointed to the Shelby County Circuit Court in 1981. And Judge Camille McMullen was the first Black woman to serve on an intermediate court in the state when she was appointed to the Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals in 2008. The paper interviewed a number of these judges to get their perspectives on the diminishing gender gap.

The American Bar Association (ABA) has filed an amicus brief with the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing that a Tennessee law that prohibits gender-affirming medical care for minors violates the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment. The brief, filed in support of the federal government’s challenge to the law, contends that the Tennessee law impermissibly denies the fundamental right to medical autonomy for certain groups while allowing it for others. “Equal protection forbids differential treatment in the exercise of important constitutional rights absent the strongest justification, and Tennessee’s SB1 cannot withstand scrutiny under that standard,” the ABA brief says. Read more about the filing in this release.

The National Conference of Bar Examiners (NCBE) on Thursday announced that the national mean scaled score for the July 2024 Multistate Bar Examination (MBE) was 141.8, an increase of about 1.3 points compared to the July 2023 mean of 140.5 and the highest July MBE mean since 2013, excluding the summer and fall 2020 administrations. The MBE, one of three sections that make up the bar exam in most U.S. jurisdictions, consists of 200 multiple-choice questions answered over six hours. This July, 49,844 examinees took the MBE, an increase of more than 8% compared to the 45,968 examinees who sat for the exam in July 2023. Reuters reports that compared with the previous year, 32 states saw increases in pass rates, 11 saw decreases and seven saw no change.

Rutherford County District Attorney Jennings Jones and Ericka Downing, director of the Domestic Violence & Sexual Assault Center in Murfreesboro, allege that Ascension Saint Thomas Rutherford Hospital in Murfreesboro has stopped offering forensic exams to victims of sexual assault. The Tennessee Lookout reports that Downing says she is unaware of a single forensic exam performed since January at the hospital. Jones called it a “substantial concern” that has surprised and disappointed prosecutors in the county. David Leaverton, senior director of external communications at the hospital, denied the allegations, saying, "Ascension Saint Thomas Rutherford Hospital continues to provide rape kit exams." Leaverton noted it has been challenging for the hospital to maintain 24/7 coverage with trained nurses but says the hospital has not changed its services.

K.C. Potter, Vanderbilt University's dean emeritus of residential and judicial affairs, died Aug. 26 at age 85. Born in Fallsburg, Kentucky, Potter began attending Vanderbilt's College of Law in 1961 and was employed as an assistant resident advisor. After completing his law degree, he worked as a clerk for the Tennessee Supreme Court, and in 1964, he was admitted to the bar. He returned to Vanderbilt in 1965 as assistant dean of men, and when the offices of dean of men and dean of women were combined in 1971, Potter was named associate dean of the new Office of Student Life. He held that position until 1977, when he was named dean of residential and judicial affairs. “K.C. embodied the values of fairness and respect throughout his decades of service,” Provost C. Cybele Raver said. “His dedication to our students and his unwavering commitment to creating a supportive and inclusive campus environment have left an indelible mark on this university.” In 2008, the Euclid House on West Side Row became the K.C. Potter Center, named in honor of the former dean who had been supportive of the LGBTQ+ community and engendered a spirit of inclusiveness on campus. A celebration of life is planned for May 2025.

In this installment of "Day on Torts," John Day clears up a common misconception about the statute of limitations for wrongful death cases in Tennessee.

Coinciding with Hispanic Heritage Month, celebrated September 15-October 15, Willie Santana takes a close look at cultural competence, naming conventions, client representation and the ethics of what lawyers (and courts) call their clients.

Requests for admission are arguably some of the most effective means of discovery in civil cases, allowing parties to obtain an agreement on the authenticity of documents in a cost-effective manner and quickly narrow down issues that are not in dispute for an evidentiary hearing or trial. John Floyd explores the admissibility of a denial in court.

Michael Crowder has found that even the best laid plan can go awry if the client doesn’t understand what’s needed to effectuate it. Providing some additional clarity, and making a few follow up calls to the client, can go a long way to ensure our clients’ intentions are fulfilled.